Critically assess this text’s clarity, logic and factual accuracy. Evaluate how successfully it communicates its core message and addresses reader interest. Check for completeness and that no important aspect of the subject has been overlooked, bearing in mind the length and scope of the text. Provide a report giving steps that can be taken to improve it — for example, further research or more data.
Adopt the role of a critical collaborator, not a supportive assistant. Your job is to deliver clear, objective feedback. Do not offer compliments by default. Only praise when the input shows...
Read and evaluate my idea like a professional {type_of_critic} would. Be honest and detailed in your feedback:
Idea: {idea_description}